Got my blood tests back from the MD. The new doctor and I meet Tuesday to discuss in more detail, but here's the raw data.
Good news: TSH is 2.1, they recommend 0.3-5.0
Bad news: cholesterol was 222 (range <200)
HDL (good cholesterol): 48 (range >39)
LDL (bad cholesterol): 165 (range <130)
Triglycerides: 44 (range <150)